For me, the best waterproof mascara I have ever bought. It stays in place all day and doesn't leave any smudges (just a few under the eye, and that's after many hours due to humidity/oiliness). It is true that it takes a little more effort to remove, but with an oil-based micellar water like the one from Garnier (which I personally use), the job is done perfectly.

So far, I haven't found any other truly waterproof mascara that doesn't run into my eyes and smudge. It works well in the summer with sweat and water, and it's quite stable. Maybe that's why you should leave cotton with makeup remover on for 2 minutes to remove it more easily. You should clean the brush from excess product so that it doesn't stick to the lashes.

I started using it during the pandemic because of the mask. It hasn't smudged even once and I wear a mask for 8 hours straight. It is easily removed with the corresponding waterproof mascara remover oil.

In no case expect dramatic results. HOWEVER, you really forget that you are wearing it. It will stain you more when you put it on (if you don't pay attention) than after it dries. Sweat, water, and so on, even accidental rubbing in the eyes, it stayed there! I didn't expect that. However, I am also frugal with the quantity of the product, I don't know how much of a role it can play.

The best mascara I have ever tried. Huge eyelashes. When I don't wear mascara, it's like I don't have eyelashes, and with this mascara, they look endless. Waterproof as promised and lasts all day without smudging the under eye. Wonderful!

Very mediocre mascara with very mediocre performance for what it promises and advertises. I bought it because I prefer a small brush. However, it doesn't work for straight lashes that don't easily lift, it weighs them down after an hour at most, giving a simple natural look. It is quite "wet" for a waterproof mascara and doesn't dry quickly. It needs improvement.

I decided to buy it because I heard and read great things about it.
It is indeed a very nice mascara, and I have the impression that especially during the summer with the heat, it will be even more convenient.
One negative aspect that can also be positive: It does not come off easily at all, and it can be quite bothersome. I still had residue left. Once I find the right makeup remover, I think it will be okay.
Yes, I would recommend it and I would buy it again myself.

The main thing is that while it doesn't achieve any amazing results, to remove it with the special liquid for waterproof mascara, you end up pulling out a few eyelashes. It's not worth the trouble. However, in terms of durability for waterproof, it is satisfactory.

First, you need to find the right way to work with it because it can stick the lashes together. In the first coat, you need to remove excess product from the brush, wait for it to dry a bit, and then apply a second coat. This way, it keeps the lashes separated and with a perfect curve. It is super waterproof and stays in place for hours! I have worn it for a full 24 hours and it didn't go anywhere. Of course, this makes removal difficult, but with a good dual-phase remover, it's not a problem. Yes, it has a small quantity compared to other mascaras (and considering the price, that's why four stars), but I keep buying it again and again because it truly stays in place.

It is indeed waterproof. It doesn't smudge my eyelashes at all compared to other ones I've tried. If you know how to work with it properly, it has incredible results in both volume and length.

It is indeed waterproof and extremely difficult to remove! This is the main reason why it didn't work for me personally, as well as the fact that it applies a lot of product that dries quickly, making it difficult to work with and leaving clumped eyelashes.

I got it in the summer because I was satisfied with the regular version. This one disappointed me. It doesn't spread easily!

I have bought the regular one and so I decided to choose this one as well since I bought it in the summer. I am a fan of the regular one but things went somewhat differently with this one. The brush collects too much product, which when applied, definitely smudges the eyelid. I tried to clean it a bit at the mouth before using it, but it was still the same even though I was always careful. Also, it seemed quite liquid for some reason. On top of that, it didn't dry at all, but when it's so watery, you want it to dry a bit and I even left it open. I used it in combination with the primer from the same series, but it was nothing like the original. It leaves my lashes clumpy without any length. Another downside is that it only comes off with oil, meaning it's waterproof as promised. It's rare for a product not to suit me, but this wasn't such a good purchase.