Very nice color (it would be), so the 1 star is only for that and the packaging. Other than that, it doesn't "show" AT ALL. You have to apply it 15 times for a faint bit of color to appear. Performance 0.

It is the first time I use eyeliner so I was cautious. I found it extremely easy to use, I had no difficulty at all, it stays in place under normal conditions without heavy sweating for over 10 hours. It is easily removed.

While it had made a very positive impression on me and had a nice result, after a while of use it caused irritation in the corner of my eye and I had to use an antibiotic ointment

While it has a nice fit and the brush is perfect, it doesn't last at all! If you tear up a little, it comes off. I wonder about the reviews that say it's waterproof

I give it 4 because as a waterproof, while I teared up, the corner came off. Otherwise, it is fantastic. Intense color and precision

Very good, it lasts a long time and is hard to remove. For me, who tears up easily, it never caused me any problems!

As for the color, it is intense and easy and correct to apply. Unfortunately, after 2 uses, the brush bristles spread out. Also, in the summer it doesn't stay on the skin and comes off... I thought from the comments that I had finally found the perfect product but unfortunately only disappointment.

Its color is intense black, the tip is very convenient for thin or more dramatic lines, and it comes off very easily with makeup remover without rubbing. I have hooded eyelids, so I have to wait a bit for it to dry, but then it stays in place for over 10 hours without smudging at all! I've been using it for a while and it has never disappointed me. For its price, it is incredibly high quality, I highly recommend it.

It is very easy to use, with intense color. The brush helps a lot with the application, the best I have ever used. However, I got it for its staying power. Other eyeliners don't stay on me because my eyes water, and this was recommended to me as the best. It is not that much better than other waterproof ones. It is indeed very stable, but not at the corners of my eyes, which water during the day. If you don't have such issues, I highly recommend it.

Very easy to correct mistakes until it dries, and extremely stable all day once it dries, even on oily eyelids! Easy application and very nice color payoff. Indeed, a few bristles of the brush "fan out" after a while, but it doesn't affect the application. The best I've tried so far!

When I tried it for the first time, I was thrilled; it has a vibrant color with lasting power, it applies easily as the brush glides smoothly with good flow. After two months, it started to leak excessive ink; every time I open it, I have to wipe it on the sides to collect the running ink, and again if I manage to make a line without it running again and smudging everywhere. I store it upright, but still the same issue. I will buy another one to see if it was just a fluke.

Thanks to this eyeliner, I learned to draw the line correctly; it has the ideal brush so that you have the option to make a thin or thicker line. It lasts long and does not cause irritation. The minus one star because the bristles from the brush lose their shape inside the cap.

I usually buy different eyeliners to see which one works best for me. This one was very good! It's one of the few that I would buy again. Very convenient brush, and very forgiving with mistakes in the outline. I wouldn't say it's the most waterproof I've used, but it stayed in place for about 5-6 hours. Since I have sensitivity with my eyes, I didn't want something that would irritate me. This one suited me very well. It won't last for 12 hours; it will have smudged by then.

It is fantastic to use, with a fine precision brush, intense black, lasts and doesn't "run." I remove one star only because after a while the bristles on the brush open up and shed. I have been using it for years for all the above reasons, but it always happens unfortunately.

Very good, indeed waterproof but I faced a problem with the product as packaging. I had it for 1 month and it came off, it broke by itself, it got stuck and wouldn't open. I don't know if it was just my luck, but that was the only thing that upset me!

While the black one is truly flawless and lasts for months, for some mysterious reason the brown brush is always problematic....

Well, it doesn't budge at all, and the paint I slept in (it was difficult at night) didn't come off. The only negative I noticed is that some little hairs on the brush came off, but nothing that is bothersome. I will definitely buy it again!

THE BEST of all that I have used!
It is the first time that I make a perfect line in one go!
Also, it is so perfect at the tip that it creates a wonderful fine line in places where we don't want it to be too visible!
The product comes out without needing to be pressed!
AMAZING!!!

For me, the top one is from essence. This one is very good with a nice finish and it really lasts. I was a bit disappointed that it wasn't a very intense black..!! The brush got ruined and the pen opened

It seemed very good to me and it has lasting power for its price. Nice application with the brush and intense black color

The best purchase I have made in eyeliner, the color is intense black, it applies easily, it lasts a long time even on oily skin, and it is very easy to remove..

I give it a star because the brush takes some of the color of the foundation/concealer and then it does not have good color performance. For this reason, I have it turned upside down so that the ink falls on its brush. However, the color is very nice, it gives a natural result on the eye, and it is easy to use.

Clean 5/5 because it is an incredible eyeliner.
It lasts all day, its color is pitch black as it should be, it has a very nice brush that helps with details. However, it requires attention because sometimes if you leave it upside down, it tends to leak more than it should, which is highly logical.

After a few applications, the color did not come down on the entire nose, so I couldn't make a thin line, only a thick one. Good for 2 applications.

I was not satisfied at all.. as if it didn't have enough product inside.. what can I say.. it was almost finished.

Easy application, convenient packaging. I bought it after reading the reviews and searching for a good eyeliner that is easy to use, as I struggled with application. I ended up with this one. Nice application, it suits me very well. However, personally, it doesn't last. At most, 1-2 hours and then it disappears. I don't know if I'm doing something wrong, but it definitely doesn't have lasting power.

I see that this particular product has very good reviews, but for me, I don't think it's worth it. I am very into makeup and I haven't seen anything worse than this. It has a strong effect, it's true, it has glitter on top, it's true, but it's only good for a few hours. Why do I say that? Because it smudges and leaves color bubbles when I open the cap. I want to emphasize that I keep it with the tip facing upwards so that it doesn't leak, but it still does the same thing. I have done great makeup with it, but it has also ruined quite a few as the line would smudge on my eye. I don't know if I got a defective one, but I wouldn't buy it again. That's it.

I consider it a good product. Easy application. Intense and long-lasting results and easily removed with makeup remover.

It has a very thin tip, which makes application very easy. Sometimes it needs a second pass to make the line darker

The best eyeliner I have ever tried. Now that I found it, I won't let it go...

Update: after a while, it started smudging a lot on the eyelid and creates a mess. I never had a problem applying eyeliner before, but now I do. I don't know why this happened. From 5/5 stars, it definitely goes down to 2.5/5