Tragic. It's going in the trash. It can't be sharpened and there's no way to get the tip out further once it's finished. Wasted money.

It is a soft, very good and stable eye pencil. The 4 stars are because it is relatively small, it needs frequent sharpening so it runs out quickly. In conclusion, it is good but for me not so much value for money

The Deep onyx and striking navy are excellent, they don't smudge and are long-lasting. Do not get the 902 at all, it doesn't paint at all, it can't even be used as kajal

I don't know what you're supposed to do to get the tip out of this. It doesn't sharpen because it's plastic and it doesn't have a base at the bottom to twist, like mechanical ones do.

I saw on Youtube that you're supposed to put a stick to push the tip upwards, what a hassle. Just the packaging alone is a tragic product.

It doesn't even last long enough to be worth it, there are more user-friendly pencils out there. Truly disappointing for a company like Maybelline.

I couldn't scratch it at all to renew the tip and I had to go on YouTube to see how it's done. Very difficult to use in this aspect, there is not even a way to push the tip out. And it takes a lot of effort to remove it.

Unfortunately, it is not waterproof at all.
It kept running constantly.

The waterproof pencil from Kryolan has saved me!

The best eyeliner I have ever used, it applies easily, has intense color (I have it in black and brown), the only one that doesn't smudge at the end of the day or when you touch your eyes. I read in the comments that it didn't come off for some people, but for me, with just one swipe of micellar water, it comes off right away and doesn't leave any tint

I have sensitive skin and the problem with pencils is that they smudge. This one simply stayed in place without smudging on a very hot day!

I bought the dark blue shade and I only wore it once because I started to feel discomfort in my eyes, like a burning sensation. It wouldn't come off no matter what. I wouldn't buy it again.

I bought it in black and I really like it. I just don't know how to refill it in case the first dose runs out... if someone knows, I would be happy if they could help me

Very nice for everyday use. Although I am quite fair, I can't say that the rose gold shade stands out, but it is a color that blends with the skin. It lasts all day and I will definitely try some other shades.

Excellent product, just be careful when removing it to use a dual-phase cleansing lotion specifically for waterproof makeup!