Whether good or bad, it is the only decently functioning solution. I got it as a replacement for the old model after an intermediate test of a similar metallic one with disastrous results and double the purchase cost. The advantages are mentioned by other buyers. The only observations I have to make are:
The large paper roll requires a small diameter on the cardboard axis - otherwise, it does not fit.
The plastic "ears" that attach to the front do not fit perfectly. [maybe it only happens with mine] I fixed it by using hot air.
The "spice shelf" at the top is extremely shallow, which means it is dangerous for any tall container placed there. I took advantage of it [see photo] by placing the roll with the single-use refrigerator bags and the kitchen timer there, with a magnetic base on the wall.