The treats turned out to be moldy, even though the expiration date wasn't close. We opened them and they arrived already moldy. We didn't even use them, which you can tell by the weight.

Excellent treat just like everything we have tried from carnilove. It smells pleasant, it's crunchy but not too hard. It is a bit big for a small dog like mine, so we usually eat it when we relax, usually after a walk.