I bought them with hesitation due to the negative reviews. I don't know if it was just luck, but our pair of Noosa tri 15 turned out great and the little one has really enjoyed them. He has been wearing them for exactly a year, with 3 track practices a week, of course also at school where he plays soccer with his classmates, they have been in the washing machine over 20 times and have shown minimal wear on the front part of the shoe with which he kicks the ball.
This year, of course, they don't fit him anymore, but I will buy the same ones again.
The photos are after a year of use.. The conclusions are yours.

These are not shoes for children, as they do not have anything durable in the front part. With the use that is made, they tore in front very quickly. I do not recommend them

They started tearing apart from the first two weeks and not only in my son's case but also in two other classmates who have bought the same ones. We wasted our money

No durability shoes. We have them for a month and they have already torn in the front. It is not justified for a child to wear them for a month and for them to become like this. It should be noted that my child does not break shoes, as soon as we got them, the first week I put them in the washing machine and immediately they tore in the front.