The story begins when Tommy helps two members of the Salieri family escape an ambush. As a reward, he is hired as a driver and soon becomes a full member of the mafia. As he carries out missions such as robberies, assassinations, and business protection, he begins to question the world he has entered. His relationship with Don Salieri, his friend Paulie, and the violent Sam is tested, while his love for Sarah drives him to seek a way out.
The plot culminates with betrayals and conflicts between the Salieri and Morello families, and eventually Tommy cooperates with the police to take down the organization. The game ends with a dramatic finale highlighting the cost of life in organized crime.