I've been using it since 2011... I bought the new packaging (almost the same on the outside) two months ago, at the same price and half the quantity!!!!!! which was dried out since I opened it... I thought it was a defective batch, so I bought a second one the same..... the worst, I won't buy it again

Good but it dries immediately. You have to take out the amount you want and not leave it open because it dries out!

Very good!!! It lasts for hours!!!
The brush didn't suit me at all. Better with an angle brush!

I am a big fan of jar eyeliner and I thought that since my old one broke, I would trust this one. From the moment I received it, it was already quite dry and did not spread very well. I added drops to make it a paste and everything was fine. I left it for a week or two and I see that it has dried up again, which disappointed me a lot because the drops I used are from Inglot and whenever I use them, they keep the product fluid. And yet, it ultimately didn't work and it's a shame because I haven't had it for very long. I wouldn't recommend it unless I got a defective one.

I have been using eyeliner pens for years and I thought I could handle this one too. Unfortunately, this product did not work for me at all. I believe it is not user-friendly and it does not create thin and clean lines on the eye.

I applied it at 21:30 and by 01:00 it was barely visible anymore. I have been using eyeliner for 12 years and I decided to try something different from my usual. Even on oily eyelids, it didn't work at all. It's a shame that I wasted my money because the quantity is not worth the 11€ I paid for it.

The formula of the eyeliner is very good and easy to use. It is a strong black, provides good coverage, lasts for hours, 12+ and comes off relatively easily with eye makeup remover. (It is better to use micellar water). However, the brush, as it came to me, needed a little shaping, so I had to trim it with a small pair of scissors to achieve a more intense angle and to make it more precise and thin.

If you know how to use it, it's the best. Very intense, waterproof color. For eyeliner, under-eye line instead of pencil or for a smudgy effect with the sponge. It doesn't irritate the eyes, it only comes off with makeup remover. The downside is that it dries a little in the jar over time since it's in a paste form, but if you wipe the brush with a little oil before application, there is no problem.

Very good. Quite stable, very good color performance, very convenient brush. It is very easy to work with... it doesn't dry out as long as you press it occasionally with a tissue on top, it lasts a long time and it is economical. I prefer it over Inglot's.

Very easy application, intense color, the brush should be washed frequently to avoid clumping. Overall excellent product, outperforms others that cost ten times as much. Just be careful to close the jar tightly so that the gel doesn't dry out.

I bought it based on the comments about its durability.
I applied it on the wet line of my eye and it doesn't stay at all.
I was disappointed, unfortunately.
I will not buy it again

It's amazing. I bought it for €5.5 and I use it on the lower lash line. It doesn't smudge no matter what happens! No comparison to eye pencils. Intense color, very long-lasting and waterproof.

It is a very nice eyeliner and the brush helps a lot on its own. It has good lasting power, intense results, and is very easy to use and apply. You can easily create thin and thicker lines

It is the second time I buy it and I will continue to use it. It is a bold matte black and stays quite stable all day.

I give it 4 stars only because if you accidentally go off the line a little, it is very difficult to correct because it is very stable and dries straight away. However, this is also good because it doesn't smudge as much as liquid eyeliners. It has a strong black color. I wouldn't recommend it for people who are just starting with eyeliner because it is more difficult to apply than a liquid one. Very good product!!!

Nice product! The jar is very beautiful, the brush is very convenient for application. On one side, it has bristles and on the other, a sponge that provides a nice blend. It has intense results and long-lasting effect. The only negative is that it is not easily removed with makeup remover.

Excellent! With almost daily use, it lasts for a year for sure, so it's definitely value for money. Since it's a gel, it's obvious that if you don't close it well, it dries out. Tip: Leave it upside down when storing it so that the oils don't stay at the bottom, it maintains better this way

Very good product according to its price. Even though I left it open and it dried out one night, it still applies relatively well. It leaves intense color and the brush is excellent in the beginning (6 months) with daily use, but then it starts to wear out. I would buy it again!

The application is very easy to use and the performance is very good, but it doesn't come off at all, meaning you can't fix any mistake or imperfection with an eraser.

I read that the product dries out... of course, you don't close the jar after each use, which is logical... the brush should be cleaned after each use or at least closed with the cap it comes with... the color is quite intense, just as it should be... I have been using it for many years, daily and for hours... more than 10... it doesn't fade in heat or if you sweat, it will make you "cap" from one of the best products, I wouldn't change it for any other... it's worth its money... so much that I don't even remember when I bought it... I use it daily and if I go out at night, even after two, if I haven't removed it, it still looks like I just applied it... ;) I had tried various others in the past... with the color fading to a lighter shade of gray while it was supposed to be black... with it fading away after a few hours... with it making "caps" in heat... I highly recommend it :P

Perfect eyeliner, the brush is convenient and if you make sure to close the jar tightly, it easily lasts for several months. I've had mine for a year and it's still like new. I will definitely buy it again!

Economical, with great durability. With this, I can take a regular bath and it doesn't "run" even in the summer, despite sweat. JUST make sure not to rub your eyes, of course.
It has a slight difficulty in washing off, but this may be due to the fact that I use very gentle cleansing wipes due to sensitivity.
The brush allows for very comfortable use, but girls, you have to clean it. Don't leave it with makeup on top!!
For its price, it is very reliable, I have been buying it continuously for 4 years!

I bought it because it had good reviews, but it didn't work for me at all, even though I am a makeup artist. If you want a good and affordable eyeliner, get the one from NYX

This product is simply wonderful, the brush doesn't help much in making a thin line but with an eyebrow brush it's perfect for achieving a flawless result with this eyeliner.. the color is intense, long-lasting, and has great staying power.. what else do we want!

For a gel eyeliner, it is truly exceptional and even better than much more expensive ones. The color is uniform and lasts all day. I don't prefer the brush, but it suits many people, it's a matter of preference. Now, yes, after a while it dries out, especially if the jar is not closed properly, but it is a product that is meant to dry out essentially, so it is perfectly expected. With a lot of care and a little oil, it becomes like new.

Intense result with minimal quantity. Really great product, highly recommended!!! It is a bit difficult to remove, but it lasts. The only negative is the brush, but that can be replaced as long as the product is good.

As a beginner, it was the only eyeliner that suited me. The brush is good and convenient, but I changed it along the way. The gel is stable, black, and lasts all day. It dried out once because I left it without a cap, but with a little contact lens solution, it became like new.

Although it had good results, the brush is not at all convenient. It also dried out almost immediately and the whole package went to waste. I would not recommend it