Excellent eye liner!!! I bought the blue color before the holidays and I was thrilled!!!! It stays on even in the sea, has intense color, doesn't smudge, and after a night out it was still in place. The brush personally worked well for me. HOWEVER, the black and brown do not have the same lasting power and color intensity.

I got the shade 02 Ash Brown, which starts off as a dark brown and after 1-2 hours ends up as a washed-out grey. Also, the brush is extremely thin, which is not easy to use for inexperienced users. Moderate lasting power, if you sweat in the summer it smudges.

While the color is really intense, it causes irritation in my eyes, and when I remove it, my skin where it was applied is red and stings.

As for the brush, I can't say it offers you much precision; you need to have a steady hand on your own.

4 stars only because it's not waterproof! Very good eyeliner, the thin brush has been very helpful! I would buy it again!

Waterproof unfortunately makes my eyelashes stick together and smudges after about 2 hours. Overall, it doesn't last long. And the application is difficult, I would say the brush is not convenient

The best liner I have ever purchased.....I wear it from morning till night and it doesn't budge....It comes off easily with micheler

The brush is very thin and definitely helps with precision. Personally, it doesn't suit me, I'm used to a slightly thicker one and it looks bad to me.
It's not waterproof, I don't know what happened, how I got confused, whether it's my fault or not..
Otherwise, it's easy to use, it comes off easily and its price is very good, but that's about it.

I didn't notice that it wasn't waterproof and I bought it because I have previously bought a waterproof one from essence. It applies nicely, it is intense but it doesn't last, maybe because it's summer. I will see now that the weather will cool down

Fantastic eyeliner, the most affordable on the market that delivers on its promise of being waterproof... I wore it all day at work, came home and there was not a trace of smudging, the color remained just as intense as when I applied it in the morning and it didn't transfer onto my eyelid. The only downside is that you can feel it on your eyes all day.

It is very good and economical. It did not cause me any allergies and it has a very stable result. The only downside is its brush, which initially did not suit me for application, but over time you get used to it.

Very good eyeliner with a precision brush, dries quickly. It doesn't last all day and it's not waterproof. However, it's quite affordable and cruelty-free!

I gave it three stars because I would like a slightly better brush! It is very thin and doesn't help much!

I love it!! It has a perfect application.. and duration. If you have oily skin, I suggest getting the waterproof one to be sure that it will stay.

It is the PERFECT of perfect eyeliners! Never stop producing it! The best there is! And I have tried many!

Long-lasting product, perfect application. I have bought it more than 10 times!!! I highly recommend it without hesitation.

Expensive brush, intense black color with one stroke very, very long-lasting even on my oily eyelids. Fantastic product! And at an incredible price

Very good brush and precise..if you want an eyeliner that stays on with the first line, I recommend it.

It may be the best eyeliner I have ever tried, and I have tried many at different prices. This one pleasantly surprises me and exceeds your expectations for such an affordable product, in terms of intensity and duration. I am very satisfied and will buy it again and again

Very good eyeliner. Truly waterproof, it stays all day where you put it, it doesn't smudge, it has intense black color, and it is relatively easy to remove with soap, unlike other waterproof ones that even laser can't remove. The applicator has a brush tip, not a marker, but unlike others, the bristles have a normal size density and finish, making it easy and precise to apply. In terms of quality-price ratio, I have no words. Generally, I don't particularly like essence products. I have liked very few of them. I trusted the reviews for this one and I did well. Much better than many high-end products that I have bought over time and disappointed me.

It is the same quality as the black eyeliner. Nice, affordable, stable, and very easy to apply.

Personally, I switched from Erre Due eyeliner (they stopped producing the one I used to buy) and this is the only one that has worked for me. The brush is indeed long, but I consider it a personal matter, meaning it suited me very well. It lasts all day and comes off easily with a wipe or any makeup remover. Plus, the price is great. I highly recommend it without a second thought.

Finally, a full black eyeliner that stays on the eye and doesn't smudge! I have oily eyelids and it didn't smudge at all!

If you are going to buy a drugstore eyeliner, this is the top one. It has an incredible quality-price ratio. Very precise brush, satisfactory quantity, and long-lasting result even on hooded eyelids, which tend to be more oily. It is truly waterproof, unlike other more expensive ones that falsely claim to be. It easily competes with other eyeliners priced at 20-25€.

Not at all convenient the brush it offers, it is excessively long and thus makes the application of eyeliner very difficult... I do not recommend it.

When I first saw the price, I was surprised, but I had nothing to lose. With this product, I have achieved the best eyeliner wings. Many people ask me which one it is and how much I paid for it, and they are surprised, just like I was at first. It is the best compared to other eyeliners that I have spent around 20 euros to buy.

Unbelievable product, wouldn't change it for anything. I first bought it years ago when I was still learning how to apply makeup, and now that I invest in more expensive cosmetics and have tried other eyeliners, I still prefer it. I highly recommend it.

Good but when you close it, paint comes out on the outside from the bottle, so it needs wiping after each use.

Truly perfect eye-liner. Its price won't deceive you. It applies flawlessly, lasts all day, and has never caused any irritation to my eyes. It's impeccable!